.
Feedback

Would You Report Your Neighbor for Burning Wood on a Spare the Air Day?

In two years, the Bay Area Air Quality Management District has collected $800 in fines for illegal residential wood burning.

Today is the third winter Spare the Air day of the year. That means that burning wood, fire logs or solid fuel will be banned both indoors and outdoors for 24 hours.

Last winter, the Bay Area Air Quality Management District received 3,777 citizen complaints about residential wood burning during the season’s 15 Spare the Air days. Those complaints resulted in a total of 346 warnings to wood burners in nine counties and 13 tickets carrying a $400 fine (See table below).

Aaron Richardson, a spokesman for the BAAQMD, said by email that the agency has only collected $800 in fines from the previous two winters, but that the chief point of banning wood fires on certain winter days is about improving air quality, not raising revenue. He added that early studies suggest that wood burning may be down by 15 percent from five years ago.

Here’s Richardson on how the BAAQMD enforces wood burning bans:

“We have about 70 inspectors on staff, and though not all of them are dispatched at any one time for wood burning duty, we send out patrols of various sizes on Winter Spare the Air days, depending on the day and availability.

“Inspectors must witness and document a violation to issue a citation.  We track all complaints received and use those to help plan neighborhoods to patrol.

“They look for smoke, and are trained in smoke plume recognition and opacity, and they must go to the physical location of the fire to determine and document the source before writing a citation.”

Warnings and Tickets Issued for Wood Burning on Winter Spare the Air Days Winter 2010-2011 (4 days of ban) Winter 2011-2012 (15 days of ban) County Warnings Tickets Warnings Tickets Alameda 5 0 10 0 Contra Costa 5 1 57 4 Marin 5 0 48 3 Napa 0 0 51 1 San Francisco 0 0 1 0 Santa Clara 13 1 32 2 San Mateo 2 0 31 1 Solano 0 0 8 0 Sonoma 29 0 108 2 Total 59 2 346 13

Source: BAAQMD

This season, first time offenders, who would have previously received a warning letter, will now be obliged to take an online class on the public health impacts of wood smoke.

Would you report your neighbor? Why or why not? Tell us in the comments section below.

Mike Dubinsky January 9, 2013 at 12:47 pm
I would not report a neighbor for a violation of the STAD rule. I only wish more citizens had shown up to oppose the rule making several years ago. I wrote letters to the BAAQMD, testified at a public hearing but as I recall only a small number of citizens opposed making the STAD a mandatory requirement punishable by a fine rather than a voluntary request. I agree with the points made about the growth of the BAAQMD into a bureaucracy who cannot figure out what really counts. At the time of the rulemaking I submitted scientific reports indicating that a large portion of the particulates were coming from Asia which they conveniently ignored.
Jason H. January 9, 2013 at 01:36 pm
No way. If I thought it was a problem, which I can't imagine I would, I would talk to them about it.
Lilian Ramey January 9, 2013 at 01:59 pm
No need to apologize Kate, it wasn't you that took this off-topic.
Geoff Burton January 9, 2013 at 03:54 pm
absolutely not
Davis January 9, 2013 at 06:02 pm
I wouldn't fink on a neighbor but I would certainly make some calls if one of these bureaucrat inspectors was abusing "company time", but in reality, they probably drive unmarked cars!
Nadja Adolf January 9, 2013 at 09:52 pm
I think a lot of people wrote letters - but nothing will stop a bureaucrat from enlarging a fiefdom. Since managerial pay in civil service is largely based on how many employees are supervised, there is absolutely no incentive to downsize any agency.
Diane Griego January 9, 2013 at 09:54 pm
Kate, you are obviously part of the liberal anything goes mentality that has brought society to this sad state. We tolerate anything and just call it love, even if it kills millions. Yeah that makes sense, whine and rat out those that you will not tolerate who burn wood on the wrong day but spend millions of tax dollars to support and encourage a disease ravaged immoral lifestyle that kills millions. And why do you call morality and facts hate or judging? Please stop the intolerance against those of us who do not fear the politically correct lunacy that is destroying our country. Moral absolutes, boundaries and truth along with a little common sense would do those who judge moral folk would correct so many of societies ills.
Anne Quint January 9, 2013 at 09:55 pm
What happens to people who have no other heat than what they burn in their fireplace?
Albert Rubio January 9, 2013 at 10:03 pm
you can always delete your comment, correct it and re-post. :-)
Albert Rubio January 9, 2013 at 10:10 pm
Wood is free, but not the labor, chain-saws, solar panels (subsidized) nor the wood burning stove.
Wood is free like water is free, food is free, like oil is free, you just have to go get it from the earth.
Edward January 13, 2013 at 06:26 pm
Read the rules. If the only heat you have is from Fire, then you may burn. This means if you live in the surrounding areas not fed by PG&E with Natural Gas or Electricity and must use a Gasoline Generator to produce electricity, Fire wood is prefered over Gasoline burning for heat. Clean, cured, dry firewood is not as bad as Cristmass Wrapping paper, carboad boxes and garbage being burned to give the illusion of an open hearth fire at Christmas. They try to eliminate "Decrative" Holiday Fires because they realy do not heat homes. But they are playing with "Traditions" that run deep and make people angery with Government.
Don January 13, 2013 at 08:11 pm
No.
Having keyed that, I have driven 880 at night through Hayward on winter days that truely qualify as spare the air days and breathing is a very unpleasant, and certainly unhealthy chore due to all the fireplace smoke. I am sure many are burning something other than proper fireplace wood. Come on folks, maybe 5 nights a year you could turn on your gas furnace? No? Burn coal.
Edward January 13, 2013 at 10:55 pm
You are correct. Hayward, California was hit by very high utility prices back in the early 80s and many purchased air-tight stoves that did not have EPA certs. Burning old cunstruction wood or old redwood fences creates a lot of unwanted smoke. Good Oak or Almond wood, readilly available, is also $220.00 to $300.00 a Cord and old torn down fences ARE F-R-E-E. IT IS ECONOMICS. PG&E WON'T GIVE HOME OWNERS A BREAK ON "SPARE THE AIR NIGHTS" WITH LOWER RATES SO HOMEOWNERS HAVE A CHOICE. PAY FOR MORE EXPENSIVE NATURAL GAS OR KEEP THE AIR DIRTY WITH WOOD. If they knew PG&E was going to give them a break on "spare the air nights", they would not light up. PG&E is so buzy buring down neighborhoods with outdated Gas Lines that they don't have time for "Spare the Air". Pay higher rates and they still will drag there feet on getting the Gas lines upgraded while they bonnus their Executives and charge their rate payers higher rates. If you want Clean ir, the anger should be directed againt the Utility Companies rather than Homeowners who ARE JUST TRYING TO KEEP WARM without going bankrupt..
Nadja Adolf January 14, 2013 at 05:46 am
Don't make assumptions about the fuels people burn. True, there are people who burn construction waste, cardboard, and discarded treated wood from fences. Don't make assumptions about people who burn solid fuel.
We purchased a very clean burning, low particulate output, Harman pellet stove. Although it cost several thousand dollars, it paid for itself within four years. We bought it looking ahead to things like possible recessions, layoffs, etc. Good thing we did. Every appliance we purchased has been energy star. Our washer is a front loader which uses less electricity and less water. The only incandescent bulbs in the house are the heat lamps used to heat the bathrooms and a couple of lower watt bulbs in living room reading lamps. We live in a smaller size house and have a native front yard (which requires watering once or twice a month in July, August, and September) and we grow vegetables using drip irrigation and mulch and raise chickens in the back for eggs and manure. I have three compost bins, all running year around for kitchen waste, garden leavings, and chicken manure. We understand that the electricity used here is filling someone else's air with coal smoke; and having been on reservations recently, we understand that if a modern version of "Dances With Wolves" were to be made it would be "Dances with Old Hybrid Batteries" or "Dances with Toxic Waste."
Nadja Adolf January 14, 2013 at 05:48 am
You know, if they took that $138,000,000 and used it for an incentive program to buy cleaner stoves for people, it might actually make a difference. Of course, it would still be a silly waste of tax dollars.
Edward January 16, 2013 at 08:22 pm
F L A S H . . . . A spare the air Alert has been called for Wednesday january 16th and thursday January 17th and the forcast is for continued spare the air alerts thru Monday, January 21st. Looks like the BAD AIR reported in China is comming to California this week. The winter High pressure area over the bay area is like the winter high pressure over Bejing last week that got so many comments on the patch. To bad PG&E does not participate in rate reduction on Natural Gas and Electricity on Spare the Air days.
Candice Suazo January 20, 2013 at 03:53 pm
I would. I live next to a neighbor who insists on burning wood on non spare the air days and it pollutes my backyard and filters inside my home aggravating my asthma and worsens my asthma symptoms especially when I have a cold. I have spoken to my neighbor about this but they continue to burn wood. Granted they seem to follow the rules on this but if you notice spare the air is usually lifted on the weekends and for those who love to be doing outdoor activities the air quickly becomes more polluted. If you are not a wood burner and do not live next to someone who is then it wouldn't affect you so much. It affects my health drastically and that of my family and I'm sure other citizens who love smelling the clean fresh air on weekends when they have the time to be outdoors instead of indoors during the work week. I wish the Tri-City area would ban all wood burning and follow other progressive cities such as Berkeley and Davis. Just look outside your window right now and if you can see Mission Peak your lucky because when I came home from my exercise class it was difficult to see through all the haze due to air pollution of wood burning. I could not even read my newspaper in my own living room in comfort because my neighbor chose to burn wood this morning.
Nadja Adolf January 20, 2013 at 04:05 pm
I think some people would benefit by learning how to properly use woodburners. Way too many people think they are "saving fuel" by choking the damper down and burning the wood very slowly. You can tell them by the chimney fires since the creosote and unconsumed combustibles in the smoke coat their chimneys.
Lynn Mc. January 20, 2013 at 05:23 pm
Oh modern society, what would we do if we had to go back to the day of the pioneers.
Edward January 21, 2013 at 05:12 pm
They did that with $300.00 credits on a new EPA qualified stove if you turned in your older stove upon instalation of the new stove. They had $200,000.00 to use and it was all gone in 2 days. The exchange program was hailed as a success because it cleaned up the old stoves without adding any new ones but the old stoves were not destroyed but could be re-sold outside of the bay area.
Edward January 21, 2013 at 05:20 pm
People burn what they can afford or what they can get. It is great if you have an EPA pellet stove and can afford those expensive pellets. But very few have the "LEXUS" stoves. Older homes with 1980's stoves heat with whatever they can afford. in this economy, it leaves us all wanting.
Edward January 21, 2013 at 05:36 pm
In older wood stoves, closing down the dampers was to modulate the thermal tempurature of the stove. The intake damper was used to reduce the oxygen and cool the stove when the room tempurature was at a high enough level. Modern Pellet stoves, that use special pellets, reduce the flow of the pellets so fuel is reduced, not the Oxygen giving a "Cleaner Burn". When these older stoves were sold, they would tell people they could load it up with wood before bed, turn down the Oxygen and not have to wake up at night to re-stoke the fire box. That is where most of the smoke comes from. If you put in wood and leave the intake damper open "all the way" but limit how much fuel you put in, the fire burns more cleanly but will be out in 2 to 3 hours. If you burn durring the day cleanly and use your furnace at night, you don't have to get up and stoke the fire and only use your furnace 8 hours a day and that can cut your natural Gas Usage down by 50% durring the winter for heating and hot water.
Edward January 21, 2013 at 05:46 pm
Nobody would burn wood if PG&E Natural Gas and Electricy were FREE. Unfortunatly, they are not FREE and can go up based on the Comodity markets. When fuel prices are down, people will use more and drive up the cost of fuels. If PG&E had an abundance of Natural Gas, they would not be pushing radio advertizing time to get peole to use 20% less each year. Ever live in an area that everybody is burning Coal? I Did and every morning I would blow my nose and BLACK STUFF" would pour out. "Soft Coal" is worse than "Hard Coal".
Lynn Mc. January 21, 2013 at 09:54 pm
And let's not forget the rich shareholders, we wouldn't want them to lose a penny on their returns, cough!
Edward January 23, 2013 at 10:07 pm
Update...January 23 has been called another "Spare the Air Day" and it is going to rain that day. Do they put all the days on LOTO balls and call them as they "pop UP". The PG&E ad says "Flex Your Power". Looks like the Bay Area Air Quality Control Board is doing just that. When PG&E is not selling enough Natural Gas, they get their buddies over at the Bay Area Air Quality Control Board to call another Spare the Air Day. Oh, my PG&E bill just arrived...Another
Winter Gotcha!
Edward January 23, 2013 at 10:34 pm
here is another Program worth $750.00 to replace your old stove. http://www.sparetheair.org/~/media/STA/Files/FAQ_SGV_final%2010-2012.ashx
Nadja Adolf January 24, 2013 at 12:46 am
The problem with the program is that the people who spend the money on a new stove wind up spending $1,000 or more and get no real benefit. They still can't burn on spare the air days.
Edward January 25, 2013 at 04:23 am
Update Again! Friday, January 25, 2013 is yet another spare the air day. I received the update at 2:31 pm in my inbox. Nice to know that Rain no longer cleans the air in Northern California. Like they have re-written the laws of physics. Looks like PG&E gets to sell off more of their poisonious methane Gas to us at inflated prices in Tier 2.
Edward January 25, 2013 at 04:28 am
No, they look for "Hot Spots" in infrared Satilite Cameras or high altitude photo reconisance then sent you a ticket like the do at intersection Cameras. The truth is, they have "Snitches" who hate smoke. One phone call does it all.
Edward January 25, 2013 at 04:38 am
Many counties require fireplaces have "natural Gas" burners installed with new homes or remodles. PG&E Loves this because they are less efficient than modern furnaces for more $$$$ for the Utilities. The best bet is an EPA wood stove AND a 90 % efficient Furnace for spare the air days. It also helpts to check before you light and every 4 hours because you never know when they might slip in a "Spare the Air" Alert on a day 6 hours earlyer, they gave "all Clear to burn" on their e-mail or web site. (especially when the forcast is for Rain that day).

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Union City Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Nika Megino (Editor) May 30, 2013 at 10:45 am
When is Kid's Night Out?
Pacific West Gymnastics June 8, 2013 at 09:18 am
Hey Nika, Sorry for the delay. We offer Kid's Night Out 1 to 2 times per month. We have oneRead More tonight, actually! Our full schedule is on our website (http://pacwestgymnastics.com/camps-events/kids-night-out/). Thanks!