Crime & Safety

Marc Klaas: I'm Not Convinced Sierra's Dead

Klaas says there are too many holes in the Sheriff's argument for him to believe the Morgan Hill teen is 100 percent dead.

Although authorities are currently treating the disappearance of Morgan Hill teen Sierra LaMar as a kidnapping and murder, KlassKids founder Marc Klaas isn’t convinced the public should be searching for a deceased body.

Klaas said several factors lead him to believe Sierra could be alive: The suspect, Antolin Garcia-Torres, doesn’t have a history of violence against women or children aside from one case that was dropped, a weapon hasn’t been found and a cause of death hasn’t been reported.

Morgan Hill police have evidence positively linking Garcia-Torres to the , although official charges have yet to be filed. Morgan Hill Police Sgt. Troy Hoefling said a report is being prepared for the District Attorney to review, and that it will be completed very soon in the near future. 

Find out what's happening in Union Citywith free, real-time updates from Patch.

Perhaps the most important reason Klaas can't confidently say Sierra is dead is because the teen's body hasn't be found. The , Thursday, but detectives haven't confirmed whether it's Sierra.  

“Let’s say you have children and you’ve gone through some hideous situation and the police call and say this is the guy who did it. You ask, ‘does he have a murder conviction, or a history of crime against women and children?' They say ‘well, there was one incident but it was dropped.’ You ask, ‘do you have a weapon or a body?’ They say ‘no.’ Then what you're doing is giving me an opinion based on circumstantial evidence that's found,” he said.

Find out what's happening in Union Citywith free, real-time updates from Patch.

However,  makes it difficult to confidently believe Sierra's alive. Plus, the popular cheerleader’s background disqualifies her as a runaway candidate, and why would the Sheriff’s Office say Sierra’s a murder victim unless they’re 100 percent positive? 

Then again, the , and the hope that's she's alive, prevents many from positively reaching a decision on Sierra’s condition.

“They’ve been vague with telling us what they have. They say they have his DNA on her bag, that they can place her in his car,” Klaas said. “Based on what I’ve heard, they haven’t made the case that this girl is 100 percent dead.”

Although , authorities can't release specific details because the investigation is ongoing, and are investigating Sierra's disappearance as a homicide based on information that hasn't been released to the public, Sheriff Sgt. Jose Cardoza said.

Klaas can positively say that Garcia-Torres is responsible for Sierra's disappearance, though, and says the

For previous coverage of the Sierra LaMar case, refer to the Sierra LaMar Disappearance: Comprehensive Updates and Information page on Gilroy Patch.


Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.

We’ve removed the ability to reply as we work to make improvements. Learn more here

To request removal of your name from an arrest report, submit these required items to arrestreports@patch.com.