.

The REAL Measure A1

A description of facts, and information without interpretation for the intelligent voter to decide for themselves.

With the confusion that has been generated surrounding Measure A1, sometimes it is difficult to remember that it's even a parcel tax ($12/year per household). This is meant to provide quick information, as well as the ability to seek more in-depth information for yourselves.

This first section comes from a flyer about the Oakland Zoo and A1:

OAKLAND ZOO FACTS

FACT: The Oakland Zoo is a 90-year old community-based organization located on 42 acres in 490-acre Knowland Park

FACT: The Oakland Zoo is owned by the City of Oakland and managed by a 501c(3) non-profit, East Bay Zoological Socity

FACT: The Alameda County Board of Supervisors, not the Oakland Zoo, placed Measure A1 on the November 6, 2012 ballot.

FACT: The Oakland Zoo gets less than 5% of its budget from the City of Oakland. City contribution has declined 50% in the last few years

FACT: The Oakland Zoo received the highest rating from Charity Navigator, an independent charity evaluating organization

FACT: The Oakland Zoo is annually audited by an independent public accounting firm

FACT: 30% of Zoo education programs are free; many other education programs are discounted

FACT: The Oakland Zoo has funded 200 buses (costing $120,000) to bring children to the Zoo for an outdoor, educational experience

 

MEASURE A1 FACTS

Voting Yes on Measure A1 will ensure the following:

-Animals are safe and enclosures are well maintained

-Animals receive appropriate food, heating/cooling and clean fresh watering system

-Sick and aging animals receive proper veterinary care

-Education programs stay affordable and accessible

-Protection of vulnerable wildlife, provide care for animals wounded in the wild and give sanctuary to endangered species

FACT: Measure A1 funds cannot be diverted to the State of California or local municipalities. Every penny must be spent in Alameda County

FACT: Measure A1 funds will be monitored by an independent oversight committee that will ensure the zoo is held fiscally accountable. By law, every penny must be spent on animal care, children's education programs, on-site conservation and visitor affordability and safety.

FACT: The oversight commitee is comprised of 9 members, representing 6 stakeholder groups and appointed by 5 agencies.

Appointing Agencies:

- The President of the Alameda County Board of Supervisors

-President of District 4 Alameda County Board of Supervisors

-The Mayor of Oakland

-The Alameda County Mayors Conference

-Board of Trustees of the East Bay Zoological Society

Stakeholder Groups:

-League of Women Voters

-Conservation of Environmental Group

-PTA Member or Public School Teacher

-Taxpayer

-Animal Rights

-Senior

KNOWLAND PARK STEWARDSHIP

Restoration of Arroyo Viejo Creek: The zoo works to keep the Arroyo Viejo Creek in Knowland Park clean and inhabited by native plants and animals, restoring it in partnership with local conservation groups and active volunteers from the neighborhood and community. The Zoo controls eriosion, pulls non-native,s plants natives and removed garbage from these fragile waters. The Creek Crew meets on the third Saturday of the month from 10:00 am-12:00pm and all are welcome to join. The restoration project includes educational outdoor classrooms and welcomes schools and creek educational groups to use these grounds for their programs.

Planting for Wildlife: The Zoo boasts thriving pollinator gardens, welcoming local hummingbirds, bees, beetles and butterflies. The gardens are also used to educate and inspire our guests to plant for wildlife in thier yards.

Native Tree Restoration Work: Throughout Knowland Park, Zoo staff and volunteers pull invasive plans, including French broom and plant native trees and plants, creating a haven for all local wildlife. 

ENDORSEMENTS

Measure A1 is endorsed and supported by nearly 1,000 leaders including:San Francisco Chronicle, San Francisco Bay Guardian, Animal Care Organizations (e.g. Humane Society of the United States and In Defense of Animals) and Veterinary Leaders (e..g. Alameda County Veterinary Medical Association), local Environmental and Conservation Organizations (e.g. East Bay Regional Park District, Wildlife Conservation Network, Ventana Wildlife Society, Bay Area Puma Prokect, Project Coyote, and River Otter Ecology Project), School superintendents, Community Organizations and Civic Leaders (e.g. Alameda County Democratic Party, Metropolitan Greater Oakland Democratic Club), Business Community Leaders and Regional Elected Officials (e.g. Congresseoman Barbara Lee)

CALIFORNIA TRAIL PROJECT

FACT: Measure A1 funds CANNOT be used to construct the California Trail Project

FACT: The Oakland Zoo's California Trail exhibit was approved following years of community meetings and public input. The democratic process was upheld. California Trail is a 56- acre exhibt with 20+ acres of open space habitat that will set the stage for 20-acres of exciting new exhibits featuring regionally extinct animals such as the grizzly bear and endangered animals like the California condor. As part of the project, the Zoo voluntarily committed to implement a "habitat enrichment plan" for Knowland Park, aimed at caring for and enhancing native animal and plant habitat. 

*Author's Note: Parcel taxes are written for what projects the organization CAN do with the money, not what projects they CANNOT do. To clarify this, the Oakland Zoo sent a letter to the city council, indicating that none of the Measure A1 money would go toward the California Trail Project. Because this knowledge and this letter is accessible to the people who would sit on the independent oversight committee, it can be considered legally binding (the oversight committee legally MUST hold the zoo accountable for what they say).

________

MORE INFORMATION

If this does not provide enough information, here are several links to actual documents regarding the Oakland Zoo and their intent. There have been a lot of links posted with interpretations, but these are the actual documents being mentioned, and some other links for more news and information.

If anyone reads them and has questions, please let me know and I will try to answer them.

The full Master Plan is listed here (#11) on the City of Oakland’s website. Development must be consistent with the Master Plan:http://www2.oaklandnet.com/Government/o/PBN/OurServices/Application/DOWD009157.

This does not provide much, but this is the company the zoo worked with to reduce their impact:http://questaec.com/content/projects/oakland-zoo/.

This is from 2010, it discusses the history, and what ended up happening after was that the planning commission and city council both approved.http://www.oaklandzoo.org/site/images/file/forms/zoo_improvements_myth_and_reality_march_2010.pdf.

There was a lawsuit, but the plan was upheld. Full articles don’t appear to be archived, but here’s part of it: http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-33136447.html.

Here is what the zoo sent the neighbors for their input in 2010:http://www.oaklandzoo.org/site/images/file/forms/oaklandzooimprovementplans_forcommunityinput.pdf

This is the actual 51-page CEQA document regarding the zoo from 1997.http://www2.oaklandnet.com/oakca/groups/ceda/documents/report/oak025959.pdf 

The first phase of the California Trail Project was a new veterinary hospital, which is complete. http://news.yahoo.com/grand-opening-oakland-zoos-veterinary-hospital-190031009.html

Lastly, there have been questions regarding why zoo's even matter at all. Please read this study as to why Zoos and Aquariums matter for conservation and stewardship practices: http://www.aza.org/uploadedFiles/Education/why_zoos_matter.pdf

Zoos' missions have changed over the years. They are about the conservation and preservation of all species, around the globe. This New York Times article discusses the role zoos play in conservation and the difficult choices ahead:  http://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/28/science/zoos-bitter-choice-to-save-some-species-letting-others-die.html?pagewanted=all

This was written because I was inspired by a man named Vikram and a few other confused voters with important questions. It is difficult to decide how to vote if you do not know the history of the situation. Thank you to those individuals.

I hope this helps, and regardless of how you choose to vote tomorrow, please get out there and vote! 

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Tyler November 05, 2012 at 11:16 PM
There are lies, damn lies, and the zoos "facts". Fact: the zoo executives have written this legislation to expressly allow the use of all future money for expansion, or anything else they want. Read it. It's right there in black and white. There was NOTHING 'democratic' about the zoo getting their 'master plan' past the Oakland City council. The board of the zoo is made up of real estate developers, a real estate law firm partner, business development guys with MBA's from Harvard, Cornell, JD's from private law colleges. They can say anything they want to about this and make lots of promises. But if you read the measure, you'll realize that this is a con job. It's a land grab by a shady bunch of developers with YOUR money. There are millions of dollars behind this bill, their slick mailers, cute lion signs and big SF Chronicle ad pieces. Do you really think these millions are being spent just to provide "lion treats" and zoo education programs? Alameda voters can't be that naive.
Ruth Malone November 06, 2012 at 12:19 AM
I just don't know how zoo executives can continue to have their employees spreading this total propaganda that is so easy for any voter to refute with their own eyes. To say "FACT: Measure A1 funds CANNOT be used to construct the California Trail Project" is simply fiction. There is nothing whatsoever in the fine print of the measure that precludes use of these funds to build the California Project (or any other future expansion), and in fact, in the Definitions section, it explicitly says that "construction," "expansion," and "capital facilities" are within the allowed definition of projects. Those words are not in the little box, but they are in the legal fine print of the measure, and that is what counts legally. Those words are not there by accident--every word in a measure like this is vetted. We do know that within less than a month of the project being rubber-stamped by the politically cooperative Oakland City Council, whose earlier bad decisions Oakland residents are still paying on, the zoo was out doing polling for this parcel tax. I guess zoo exceutives think Alameda County voters can't read, or that they just won't bother to read the fine print. Please visit http://www.noonmeasurea1.com/ and click the links at the bottom to see the measure itself, and our Analysis of key sections. This deceptive tactic reflects badly on the zoo. Better to be straight with voters. To say this is all about lion treats and kids' programs is just not true.
Tyler November 06, 2012 at 12:55 AM
Seems the folks at the Oakland Tribune can't find their way through the layers of smoke and mirrors on A1 either... http://www.insidebayarea.com/ci_21897206/oakland-tribune-editorial-no-measures-a1-and-u?IADID=Search-www.insidebayarea.com-www.insidebayarea.com

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something