.
Feedback

Sept. 11 Anniversary: A Look Back at the Story of San Francisco-Bound United Flight 93

The deaths of the 40 passengers and crew members hit home particularly hard in the Bay Area, where many of them had lived, leaving behind scores of grieving family members, co-workers and friends.

Sept. 11, 2001 hit home hard in the Bay Area when local residents — already reeling from images of the crumbling Twin Towers — found out that one of the four planes hijacked by suicidal terrorists was bound for San Francisco.

Many of the 40 passengers and crew members killed when Flight 93 smashed into a remote Pennsylvania field either lived here or had Bay Area ties. Even one of the pilots, Jason M. Dahl, 43, had local roots. He grew up in San Jose, graduating from San Jose State and becoming a pilot before settling down in Colorado.

While most of the attention that day was on the destruction in New York and at the Pentagon, an amazing story of courage unfolded when Flight 93 family and friends, such as Deena Burnett, who lived in San Ramon at the time, told the world that the passengers had hatched a plan to fight back.

Patch compiled this round-up of Flight 93-related stories and websites so the passengers who didn't give up won't be forgotten as the nation reflects 10 years later.


What Happened

This riveting story by Dennis B. Roddy of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette retraces with great detail everything from the plane's delayed morning takeoff to its crash around 10 a.m. and includes many personal details about the passengers as well as the four hijackers.

An excerpt:

What made Flight 93 different was a decision reached somewhere over the skies of Western Pennsylvania, after passengers learned on cell phones that they were likely to be flown into a building as the fourth in a quartet of suicide attacks.

They decided to fight.

They became the first casualties in a strange new combat against an enemy as old as hatred and as unclear as the muffled shouts and groans investigators would later hear on the cockpit voice recorder dug out of a reclaimed strip mine on a Pennsylvania hillside.

The Victims

This CNN.com Sept. 11 victim archive lists the almost 3,000 people killed, in alphabetical order, and can be sorted by name, employer, age, residence and where they died. It also includes photos of many of them.

Some of the Flight 93 passengers with Bay Area connections whose names have become more well-known include:

   * Hilda Marcin, 79, a retired special education teacher's aide who was on the flight because she was moving to Danville to live with her daughter's family.

   * Thomas Burnett Jr., 38, of San Ramon, a senior vice president and chief operating officer for Pleasanton-based Thoratec. He was among a group of passengers now known as heroes for trying to fight the hijackers.

  * Mark Bingham, 31, of San Francisco, an owner of a public relations firm. Bingham, a graduate of Los Gatos High School and U.C. Berkeley, where he played rugby, was another one of the passengers who told relatives via cell phone that they were going to fight back.

Alice Hoagland, Bingham's mother, who received a call from him during the flight, still lives in the Bay Area, near Los Gatos.

Hoagland, a board member for MyGoodDeed, continues to honor her son's memory, encouraging members of the public to perform good deeds and offer their service this Sept. 11 as a tribute.

Other Bay Area residents who died include Nicole Carol Miller, 21, of San Jose (read her family's beautiful memorial site here); Lauren Catuzzi Grandcolas, 38, of San Rafael, who was pregnant; Alan Anthony Beaven, 48, of Oakland; Wanda Anita Green, 49, of Oakland; and Andrew (Sonny) Garcia, 62, of Portola Valley.

To read about other Flight 93 victims, click here

The Union City Memorial

The first memorial built for the victims of Flight 93 ended up being in the Bay Area, in Union City, because one man, former Marine Michael L. Emerson of Hayward, was frustrated that in the year after the attacks, most of the public interest was swirling around the World Trade Center and Pentagon crashes and that at the time nothing was being planned for the crash site in Pennsylvania.

Emerson figured that since the plane was headed to San Francisco, a local memorial would make sense and would give area friends and family a place to grieve and to find hope. With the blessings of victims' family members, he got park land donated, as well as labor, and raised half a million dollars to get the memorial built within five years.

Eventually a memorial took shape in Pennsylvania, under the leadership of the National Park Foundation, and Emerson was asked to join the steering committee working on the project. The Flight 93 National Memorial, which is about 80 percent complete, will be dedicated on Sept. 10.

Read more about Michael Emerson and the San Francisco Bay Area Flight 93 Memorial. The 10-year ceremony will be held at the memorial, located off I-880 in Sugar Landing Park, on Sunday at 1 p.m.

There are other East Bay public landmarks honoring the flight. A street in Pleasanton was named Thomas Burnett Lane in Burnett's honor and his name graces a freeway overpass in nearby San Ramon. The city of San Ramon also created a memorial for Burnett in a city park, and his family created a foundation to carry on his belief in the importance of education.

Burnett's conversation with his wife Deena Burnett in the minutes leading up to the crash are heartbreaking, but their exchange is a snapshot of how the passengers found out through calling family members that the plane they were on was part of a suicide mission. It was that information that made the passengers realize they needed to, as Burnett said, "Do something."

Click the PDF at right to read a transcript of their conversation.

Bay City News contributed to this report.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Union City Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Loading comments ...
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Eileen Viray Alcones May 22, 2013 at 11:14 am
Our dog Tayey has been missing since the 17th. He is a very light tab chihuahua goes by the nameRead More Tayey. He is 17 years old. Was he taken to the animal shelter?? Pls contact me 510-396-5044
Edward May 17, 2013 at 05:05 pm
To add insult to injury, New Haven Unified just divided the community by re-naming a Middle SchoolRead More after two Phillipino labor leaders instead of an Early" Alto California", Mexican Governor after wich the Town of Alvarado was named. They created a WAR betwean comunities with flag waving and graphiti tagging damages even the police call a "Hate Crime". They should be naming a NEW High School after those two labor leaders and not just re-naming an existing historical Middle School. When push comes to shove, the New Haven Unified School Board will pay for a name change but not help pay for school supplies or keep good teachers with a good salery with benefits. They re-name a Middle School After labor leaders, but don't honor the Labor that had dedicated a lifetime to our children....Our Teachers.
Edward May 17, 2013 at 04:51 pm
Because new haven unified School District is so busy renaming or selling off Schools, they areRead More neglecting the 29.1 million dollar grant they got to help provide moderization and supplies to teachers. Instead of building a second High School, on the growing west side of union City, they sell off 15 acres and a relativly NEW, perfectly good school building just 3 blocks from a 70 year old Elementary School. When James Logan High School was Built, Union City had only 23,000 residents. Today, Union City bosts 77,000+ residents and has a single High School pushing 5000 students. Instead of building a new High School (like Fremont, that has 5 High School, one for each of ther original districts and a ROP School), New Haven Unified only has one in the Decoto District and Alvardo district residents must commute to the Decoto District to get an education beyond middle School. A 50 year old "busing policy" (without the Buses) in the name of diversity. Both sides of Highway 880 are just as diverse yet they will not build the west side a High School.
Edward May 17, 2013 at 05:16 pm
To add insult to injury, New Haven Unified just divided the community by re-naming a Middle SchoolRead More after two Phillipino labor leaders instead of an Early" Alto California", Mexican Governor after which the Town of Alvarado was named. They created a WAR betwean comunities with flag waving, fist shaking and graphiti tagging damages even the police call a "Hate Crime". They should be naming a NEW High School on the West Side of Union City after those two labor leaders and not just re-naming an existing historical Middle School. When push comes to shove, the New Haven Unified School Board will pay for a name change but not help pay for school supplies or keep good teachers with a good salery with benefits. They re-name a Middle School After labor leaders, but don't honor the Labor that had dedicated a lifetime to our children....Our Teachers.
Edward May 11, 2013 at 04:12 am
Here are some patch photos. you will notice the children marching with the" Filipino AdvocatesRead More for justice" banner all the way up to the New Haven Unified School District office. Do you think these photos could have incited the Vandels and selected their target? Violating the "Brown Act", the School Board created this problem by not putting the name change before the Voters before making this decision ahead of public comments and input. The outcome, of changing the name, and what the name would be, was already decided before they even put it on the agenda, behind closed doors. The clinched Fists, in the Top photo, did not help either. Remember, these are Patch Photos, that are public, and even more are out there in social media. http://storify.com/UnionCityPatch/a-collection-of-photos-and-reactions-to-alvarado-m/embed
Edward May 11, 2013 at 01:35 am
Dear Mr. Day: It is NOT the names of Larry itliong or Phlip Veracruz that have been at issue, itRead More has been the removal of an "existing" name, on an "existing" school, that already has Heritage Everyone agrees, that, if this was a new school, it would be good. We need a new High School on the west side of Union City because the existing School is pushing 5,000 students and is just to large and to far away. The School District is just playing politics with a "name" and not giving the Students what they realy need. They are selling off Real Estate with an existing School on the West Side, of Union City, to private developers, instead of giving us a new High School. People are fustrated with the School District and the Phillipino Comunity that pushed the name change and this is why they targetted the "Political Office" of the "Phillipino Community". This was not a random location...It was a "Shot Across the Bow". No amount of smooth talk or Guest Speakers will fix this. Only putting the name change "On the Ballot" will fix this. It must be resolved by everyone before we can "GO ON".
S T April 18, 2013 at 07:39 pm
"lost revenue from large industries that have ceased business or left the service area,Read More including NUMMI, Solyndra" What about gained revenue from Tesla and Seagate? "Labor costs are also increasing, especially the cost of health care benefits" Yeah, with average salary at $89,110 in 2011: http://fremont.patch.com/articles/how-much-employees-in-the-union-sanitary-district-earn
John April 18, 2013 at 01:14 pm
lost revenue from large industries that have ceased business or left the service area, includingRead More NUMMI, Solyndra, Borden Chemical, and SF Newspaper Group, historically some of the District’s largest customers. yet they make no mention that Solyndra will now be occupied by seagate soon, and nummi has Telsa....etc... Union City pays more than most cities in water/garbage/sewer/school parcels/sales tax yet its schools are floundering, water taste awful, you have pay to recycle
John April 18, 2013 at 01:11 pm
Spot on and to pay for their entitlements as using public vehicle to go on long trips...
Joanna Nelson March 12, 2013 at 03:07 pm
The passes will offer a $57 (90) minute session down from the introductory price of $74! Thanks soRead More much!
Lori Suydam January 26, 2013 at 02:50 pm
I am a teacher at Park Elementary School and I love what you did for our school. My students andRead More parents were so happy to see that our walls were bright and our desks were sparkling clean. Thank you very much!!
Leah Hall January 26, 2013 at 01:43 pm
Tip of the Hat to our difference makers at Kaiser!
Rob Rich January 26, 2013 at 12:29 pm
This is fantastic! Thank you Kaiser for supporting public schools and honoring the legacy of Dr.Read More King.
Edward May 14, 2013 at 04:00 pm
May 14,2013 Union City, California. Police said the first suspect pushed both homewoners down toRead More the floor and "forcefully removed the elderly female's jewelry." The second suspect found a young adult male locked in a bedroom, struck him in the head with the gun, ransacked the bedroom and took more property, police said. Both suspects fled on foot to a waiting vehicle, described as a newer model silver Audi sedan or BMW with chrome rims and tinted black windows. The vehicle was last seen being driven past Kitiyama Elementary School onto Medallion Drive, according to a Union City Police press release. Now this is about rich Black kids, with guns and driving BMWs, Attacking Elderly Whites in Union City. A little "political Vandelism" did not do this. This is a true "hate crime" against Whites yet it is reported as a "home invasion Robbery". They followed the Elderly White guy home from the store and pushed there way into the house and hurt everybody as they robbed them. Pre-selected an Elderly White Guy, because of hate" thencommited a crime against him and his family. The Political painting on a Political office was not a hate crime but a "political Statement". Get it Strait.
Edward May 11, 2013 at 04:00 am
Here are some patch photos. you will notice the children marching with the" Filipino AdvocatesRead More for justice" banner all the way up to the New Haven Unified School District office. Do you think these photos could have incited the Vandels and selected their target? Just a thought. http://storify.com/UnionCityPatch/a-collection-of-photos-and-reactions-to-alvarado-m/embed
Union City Resident May 9, 2013 at 09:44 pm
you could be on to a super idea! Online education. No ecological impacts. Everyone works at theirRead More own speed and capability. They get the best teacher every time because we can choose the lesson. Do anytime before midnight the same day if there is homework just like in college for those who sleep late and are always truant in regular school, no computer or too young and nobody at home, can go to computer centers. LOL You can name your own computer instead of school names. We can afford it better, cheaper for parents than school taxes, no administrators everywhere you look. Okay, I was just kidding...I think it's one issue at a time. School naming, school board, violating the Brown Act, address issues of recall, new elections, listening to the public, elected officials not following district policy, School Superintendent who knew or should have known it was a Brown Act violation, should be fired or not?, put issue on ballot by referendum or not?, let other elected officials write to editor instead of meeting with their voters?, Nobody trying to correct the errors made?, then discuss new high school. I agree with other letter - students being abused in school for maybe years now, bad test scores and they all say they know why but as educators they haven't fixed the problem yet, budget is non existent but we can afford all new band and athletic uniforms for the school with the new name LOL Taxpaying without representation